Letter to the Editor: Young Composers Need Alsop’s Fierce Championship

I was pleased to see last month’s conversation with conductor Marin Alsop. As everyone knows, she has been a fierce champion of new American music for many years, and her position at Cabrillo has been a great service to many composers.

It’s intriguing to hear Alsop speak about the necessity of providing experiential education for young conductors. I wish she had an equally wide-ranging vision for the music she programs at Cabrillo. Young composers like Mason Bates and Kevin Puts, and idiosyncratic established composers like Philip Glass and Lou Harrison, have appeared on Cabrillo’s programs, but there is a remarkable lack of truly adventurous programming, especially in recent years. Alsop is in a position to change that, and she has the charisma to do so effectively.

Cabrillo and its audience would benefit immensely from a more expansive approach to programming orchestral music. There are two ways to achieve this. First, commissioning established composers who have little or no orchestral repertoire would create a buzz and provide these composers with an invaluable opportunity, should they choose to accept it. Pauline Oliveros, John Moran, Pamela Z, and Henry Gwiazda, among others, could be approached with this opportunity.

Second, younger composers who have demonstrated depth of talent and convincing—if not necessarily consistent—aesthetic voices, should be programmed more frequently at Cabrillo. If there is a concern that these younger composers don’t have enough experience writing for orchestra, then Cabrillo’s senior composers could mentor them. They could even help orchestrate the younger composers’ pieces, for a portion of their commissioning fees.

It is virtually impossible for American composers outside of academic institutions to gain access to professional orchestras. Just as talented young conductors need the experience of being in front of an actual orchestra, composers need the support of beneficent curators and conductors willing to take risks. The stunted development of today’s orchestral repertoire is a direct result of the extremely limited access that adventurous composers are granted when it comes to writing for orchestra. Give them a chance. They will be grateful, and they won’t let you down.

One thought on “Letter to the Editor: Young Composers Need Alsop’s Fierce Championship

  1. Daniel Wolf

    The problem is that Cabrillo has taken one step forward and another step backward. The step forward is in labeling itself upfront as a festival of contemporary music; the festival has not suffered at all materially for this and this should encourage other programmers across the country. The step backward is in not continuing the experimental and west coast emphases found in earlier years — the composers now selected are, by and large, the same names found in more mainstream programming on the other other coast, rather than the Harrison, Cage, Hovhaness, Nancarrow, Revueltas, American Five, Other Music, Johanna Beyer, Alvin Curran, Pauline Oliveros, Charles Amirkhanian etc. programming found in the Samuel, Chavez, and Davies directorships. The present, more generic, programming is a departure from precisely that which made Cabrillo very special in the US concert landscape.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Conversation and respectful debate is vital to the NewMusicBox community. However, please remember to keep comments constructive and on-topic. Avoid personal attacks and defamatory language. We reserve the right to remove any comment that the community reports as abusive or that the staff determines is inappropriate.