Americans in Pyongyang

Americans in Pyongyang

After being firmly in the camp of folks who’ve been feeling blasé about the New York Philharmonic giving a concert in Pyongyang, North Korea, I’m now strangely excited about the whole thing. Although admittedly when I learned two weeks ago that a good friend of mine was going I became more than casually interested. But this morning is what made me completely gaga: When I logged on to CNN this morning, it was the top news story. This is the first time in my life that a report about a concert of classical music was the number 1 news item. (The only other classical music headline I can recall was the death of Leonard Bernstein.)

Of course, I’m still very disappointed that the Philharmonic didn’t use this historic opportunity to premiere a new work by a living American composer, or a living composer from North Korea, or even a non-premiere by someone who is still alive—their neglect of contemporary music was, after all, the source of my feeling blasé. My disappointment was accentuated when I heard the soundbyte of Lorin Maazel addressing the audience before leading the orchestra in a performance of An American in Paris: “Someday a composer may write a work entitled Americans in Pyongyang.”

I’ve heard the Phil under Maazel do Gershwin and thought it showed them at their best, so I’m sure they delivered the goods once again. And Dvorak’s New World Symphony, which was also on the program, seems very appropriate since it is also the byproduct of a stranger in a strange land. But what could have been a better fit with this repertoire than something created specifically for this event? Historically, most events of this type come with a new piece, from J.S. Bach’s composition of numerous secular cantatas to add pomp to important civic occasions to Britten’s opera Gloriana, written for the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II, or even Tan Dun’s Symphony 1997 Heaven, Earth, Mankind, created for a concert celebrating the reunification of Hong Kong with the People’s Republic of China.

Of course, so much can go wrong in effecting a concert in a country with which the nation the visiting orchestra has come from has no diplomatic relations. Doing a new piece might have added an element that was too unpredictable, and potentially too volatile. Or perhaps it just wasn’t a priority, which would really be a shame.

Still, getting the normally no-attention-span-for-culture-of-any-type media to give this event major airtime is really significant. No doubt it helps that it involves a country demonized for decades and largely shrouded in mystery to most of us. So what can the contemporary music community learn from all of this? Might composers be able to make headlines if we all began writing works for performance in Syria? More importantly, will the New York Phil be able to accomplish with music what world leaders have been unable to do for over a half a century? If so, perhaps there will come a time when music won’t be so marginalized in the media.

You might also enjoy

NewMusicBox provides a space for those engaged with new music to communicate their experiences and ideas in their own words. Articles and commentary posted here reflect the viewpoints of their individual authors; their appearance on NewMusicBox does not imply endorsement by New Music USA.

3 thoughts on “Americans in Pyongyang

  1. Miss Mussel

    Just as an FYI, I’ve compiled a list of media responses to this concert at The Omniscient Mussel.

    I too, didn’t expect to be so excited about the concert but as the time came closer, my interest increased.

    This is a landmark event for my generation and I’m happy that I was able to participate in my own small way.

  2. philmusic

    “… perhaps there will come a time when music won’t be so marginalized in the media…”

    Music confounds and amazes!

    Phil Fried

  3. rtanaka

    So what can the contemporary music community learn from all of this? Might composers be able to make headlines if we all began writing works for performance in Syria?

    I don’t know about making headlines, but there are already examples of these kinds of things happening…say, NPR was doing a showcase of Iraqi artists who fled the nation and came to the US a few months ago. If the interest is there, the media will cover it, usually. I think music communities in general needs to ask itself what it has to offer to the public if it really wants that kind of attention…


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Conversation and respectful debate is vital to the NewMusicBox community. However, please remember to keep comments constructive and on-topic. Avoid personal attacks and defamatory language. We reserve the right to remove any comment that the community reports as abusive or that the staff determines is inappropriate.